# Brotherhood of Thieves

American · $$ · Sit-down

**Address:** 23 Broad Street
**Phone:** 774-325-5812
**Hours:** Lunch and Dinner
**Pricing:** median item $16 (below the island median of $17).

## Menu

### Appetizers

- **Spicy Tuna Crispy Rice** — $24.00
  diced raw tuna, sweet soy sauce, wasabi tobiko, crispy rice
- **Tuna Tartare** — $20.00
  diced bluefin, avocado, micro cilantro, ginger soy, tortilla chips
- **Hamachi Carpaccio** — $18.00
  thinly slice yellowtail, micro cilantro, mustard soy sauce
- **Seaweed Salad** — $10.00
  traditional wakame style

### Desserts

- **Brohood Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae** — $15.00
  in a cast iron skillet, with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, chocolate sauce
- **Strawberry Shortcake** — $14.00
  house-made biscuit, vanilla ice cream, strawberries, whipped cream
- **Carrot Cake** — $12.00
  cream cheese frosting, pecans, caramel sauce, gluten free
- **Crème Brûlée** — $12.00
  custard with caramelized sugar and raspberries

### Blended and Single Malt Scotch

- **Dewars** — $14.00
- **Johnnie Walker Black** — $16.00
- **Monkey Shoulder** — $15.00
- **Macallan 12** — $24.00
- **Laphroig 10** — $20.00
- **Talisker 10** — $22.00

### Kids Menu

- **Cheeseburger** — $12.00
  american cheese, griddled seeded brioche, curly fries or veg
- **Grilled Chicken Sandwich** — $12.00
  griddled seeded brioche, curly fries or veg
- **Pasta** — $9.00
  with butter or tomato sauce
- **Chicken Tenders** — $12.00
  lightly battered, curly fries or veg
- **Grilled Cheese** — $12.00
  griddled american cheese, curly fries or veg

### Dessert Martinis

- **Espresso Martini** — $18.00
  triple 8 vanilla vodka, coffee liqueur, espresso, dark or creamy
- **Chocolate Martini** — $18.00
  triple 8 organic vodka, crème de cacao, cream
- **Pistachio Martini** — $18.00
  sogno pistachio liqueur, vanilla vodka, amaretto, irish cream
- **Espresso Martini** — $18.00
  triple 8 vanilla vodka, coffee liqueur, espresso, dark or creamy
- **Chocolate Martini** — $18.00
  triple 8 organic vodka, crème de cacao, cream
- **Pistachio Martini** — $18.00
  sogno pistachio liqueur, vanilla vodka, amaretto, irish cream

### Essential Rolls

- **Maki** — $15
  tuna, yellowtail or salmon with avocado
- **Spicy Maki** — $15
  tuna, salmon or yellowtail with cucumber
- **Shrimp Tempura** — $15
  avocado, cucumber, sweet soy
- **California** — $15
  crab, cucumber, avocado
- **Tuna Crunch** — $15
  tuna, avocado, tempura crunch, sweet chili sauce
- **BBQ Eel** — $15
  eel, cucumber, avocado, sweet soy
- **Essential Rolls** — $15
  $15

### Bourbon and Rye

- **Evan Williams Black Label** — $14.00
- **Elijah Craig Small Batch** — $15.00
- **Henry McKenna Single Barrel BIB 10 yr** — $25.00
- **1792 Small Batch** — $15.00
- **Michter's US*1 Small Batch** — $16.00
- **Four Roses Small Batch** — $16.00
- **Buffalo Trace** — $15.00
- **Blanton's Single Barrel** — $25.00
- **Eagle Rare** — $18.00
- **Woodford Reserve** — $17.00
- **Old Forester 1897 BIB** — $16.00
- **Makers Mark** — $15.50
- **Basil Hayden** — $18.00
- **Nor'Easter Bourbon** — $17.00
- **Rittenhouse BIB Rye** — $15.00
- **Sagamore Rye** — $15.00
- **High West Double Rye** — $15.00
- **Evan Williams Black Label** — $14.00
- **Elijah Craig Small Batch** — $15.00
- **Henry McKenna Single Barrel BIB 10 yr** — $25.00
- **1792 Small Batch** — $15.00
- **Michter's US*1 Small Batch** — $16.00
- **Four Roses Small Batch** — $16.00
- **Buffalo Trace** — $15.00
- **Blanton's Single Barrel** — $25.00
- **Eagle Rare** — $18.00
- **Woodford Reserve** — $17.00
- **Old Forester 1897 BIB** — $16.00
- **Makers Mark** — $15.50
- **Basil Hayden** — $18.00
- **Nor'Easter Bourbon** — $17.00

### Nigiri & Sashimi

- **Nigiri** — $12
  Nigiri $12 (2 pieces over rice)
- **Sashimi** — $15
  Sashimi $15 (3 pieces, no rice)
- **Bluefin Tuna**
- **Yellowtail**
- **Salmon Roe**
- **Eel**
- **Black Seabass**
- **Toro**
- **Sea Urchin** — +$5
- **A5 Kobe Beef** — +$5
- **Bluefin Tuna (Nigiri/Sashimi)**
- **A5 Kobe Beef (Nigiri/Sashimi)** — $5

### After Dinner Drinks

- **Blended and Single Malt Scotch - Dewars** — $14.00
- **Johnnie Walker Black** — $16.00
- **Monkey Shoulder** — $15.00
- **Macallan 12** — $24.00
- **Laphroig 10** — $20.00
- **Talisker 10** — $22.00

### Irish and Canadian Whiskey

- **Jameson** — $14.50
- **Crown Royal** — $14.50
- **Jameson** — $14.50
- **Crown Royal** — $14.50

### Bowls

- **Poke** — $34.00
  choice of bluefin tuna or salmon, rice, mango, cucumber, cabbage, cilantro, avocado, carrots, red onions, soy-ginger dressing
- **Salmon** — $28.00
  sliced salmon, cucumber, avocado, spicy seaweed salad, rice, fresh wasabi, ginger, cucumber, avocado, salmon roe, sesame dressing
- **Chirashi** — $28.00
  a sushi salad of tuna, salmon, yellowtail, tobiko, fresh wasabi, greens, rice
- **Salmon (Bowl)** — $28.00
  sliced salmon, cucumber, avocado, spicy seaweed salad, rice, fresh wasabi, ginger, cucumber, avocado, salmon roe, sesame dressing

### Cognac

- **Pierre Ferrand 1840** — $15.00
- **Remy Martin 1738** — $22.00
- **Pierre Ferrand 1840** — $15.00
- **Remy Martin 1738** — $22.00

### Platters

- **Nigiri Sampler** — $45.00
  1 piece bluefin tuna, salmon, yellowtail, black seabass, a5 kobe beef, toro, choice of 1 large roll
- **Toro Sampler** — $60.00
  4 pieces nigiri, 4 pieces sashimi, 1 toro jalapeño roll
- **Ferry Boat** — $100.00
  choice of 8 pieces nigiri, 9 pieces sashimi, one essential roll, one large roll

### Rittenhouse / Rye & Others

- **Rittenhouse BIB Rye** — $15.00
- **Sagamore Rye** — $15.00
- **High West Double Rye** — $15.00

### Tequila

- **La Langosta Blanca** — $16.00
- **La Langosta Añejo** — $26.00
- **Casamigos Blanco** — $16.00
- **Casamigos Reposado** — $18.00
- **Casamigos Añejo** — $20.00
- **Espolon Reposado** — $16.00
- **Don Julio Blanco** — $20.00
- **Don Julio 1942 Añejo** — $48.00
- **Clase Azul Reposado** — $38.00
- **Partida Añejo** — $18.00
- **La Langosta Blanca** — $16.00
- **La Langosta Añejo** — $26.00
- **Casamigos Blanco** — $16.00
- **Casamigos Reposado** — $18.00
- **Casamigos Añejo** — $20.00
- **Espolon Reposado** — $16.00
- **Don Julio Blanco** — $20.00
- **Don Julio 1942 Añejo** — $48.00
- **Clase Azul Reposado** — $38.00
- **Partida Añejo** — $18.00

### Large Raw Rolls

- **Endless Summer** — $24.00
  tuna, cucumber, avocado, crab stick, topped with tuna, avocado, spicy mayo, sweet soy
- **Toro Jalapeño** — $26.00
  spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with torched toro, jalapeño, tobiko, mustard soy sauce
- **Everything** — $25.00
  tuna, salmon, yellowtail, cucumber, avocado, crab stick, topped with tempura crunch, spicy mayo, tobiko
- **Triple Salmon** — $25.00
  spicy salmon, crab, cucumber, avocado, topped with seared salmon, salmon roe, spicy mayo, sweet soy
- **Dynamite** — $25.00
  spicy yellowtail, crab, cucumber and avocado, topped with spicy tuna, sriracha, spicy mayo, sweet soy, tempura crunch
- **Nantucket** — $26.00
  spicy sea scallops, cucumber, topped with tempura crunch, tobiko
- **Rainbow** — $24.00
  crab, cucumber, topped with avocado, tuna, salmon, yellowtail
- **Brohood** — $24.00
  spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with torched yellowtail, salmon, jalapeño, sriracha
- **Cisco Beach** — $25.00
  spicy tuna and cucumber, topped with seared yellowtail, spicy mayo, sweet soy, scallions, lime, tobiko
- **Angry Dragon** — $25.00
  shrimp tempura, spicy tuna and avocado, wrapped in soy paper, topped with crab stick, sweet soy, mango sauce

### Gin

- **Ford's** — $14.00
- **Gale Force Gin** — $16.00
- **Plymouth** — $15.00
- **Hendrick's** — $16.00
- **Tanqueray** — $15.00
- **Gray Whale** — $15.00
- **Bombay Sapphire** — $15.00
- **Ford's** — $14.00
- **Gale Force Gin** — $16.00
- **Plymouth** — $15.00
- **Hendrick's** — $16.00
- **Tanqueray** — $15.00
- **Gray Whale** — $15.00
- **Bombay Sapphire** — $15.00

### Large Cooked Rolls

- **Tornado** — $25.00
  shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado and crab meat, wrapped in soy paper and potato, deep fried and topped with sweet soy, spicy mayo, sweet chili
- **Shaggy Dog** — $25.00
  shrimp tempura and avocado, topped with crab stick, sweet soy, spicy mayo, mango sauce
- **Volcano** — $26.00
  crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with baked spicy scallop, crab stick, sweet soy, spicy mayo, scallion, tobiko
- **Pipeline** — $30.00
  shrimp, crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with lobster, spicy mayo, sweet soy, tobiko
- **Dragon** — $24.00
  crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with bbq eel, avocado, sweet soy
- **Caterpillar** — $24.00
  crab and cucumber, topped with avocado, sweet soy, tempura crunch
- **Veggie Futo** — $20.00
  marinated japanese veggies, cucumber, carrot, avocado
- **Samurai** — $28.00
  shrimp tempura, crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with lobster, spicy mayo, sweet soy, tobiko
- **Spicy Lobster** — $28.00
  lobster, avocado, cucumber, spicy mayo, tobiko
- **Surf and Turf** — $28.00
  shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado, topped with torched a5 kobe beef, sweet soy, sweet chili, spicy mayo
- **Kobi-Wan** — $28.00
  grilled a5 kobe beef, marinated japanese veggies, cucumber, avocado, sesame oil

### Rum

- **Plantation Stiggens' Pineapple** — $16.00
- **Hurricane Rum** — $16.00
- **Mount Gay** — $15.00
- **Sailor Jerry's Spiced** — $15.00
- **Goslings** — $14.00
- **Banks 5 Island** — $15.00
- **Plantation Stiggens' Pineapple** — $16.00
- **Hurricane Rum** — $16.00
- **Mount Gay** — $15.00
- **Sailor Jerry's Spiced** — $15.00
- **Goslings** — $14.00
- **Banks 5 Island** — $15.00

### Sake 101

- **Sake 101**
  Brewed for over 2000 years in japan, sake is a perfect pairing with sushi. Made from special types of rice, koji, yeast and pure water, sake can display a variety of flavors that range from earthy and umami to light and fruity

### Vodka

- **Triple 8 Organic** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Cranberry** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Raspberry** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Blueberry** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Orange** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Vanilla** — $15.00
- **Absolut** — $14.50
- **Belvedere** — $15.00
- **Tito's** — $15.00
- **Ketel One** — $16.00
- **Grey Goose** — $16.00
- **Triple 8 Organic** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Cranberry** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Raspberry** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Blueberry** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Orange** — $14.50
- **Triple 8 Vanilla** — $15.00
- **Absolut** — $14.50
- **Belvedere** — $15.00
- **Tito's** — $15.00
- **Ketel One** — $16.00
- **Grey Goose** — $16.00

### Sparkling Sake

- **Kikusi Shozu Funaguchi** — 9oz Can$20.00
  Japan's #1 unpasteurized (nama) sake, cask strength. Funaguchi has a rich, full-bodied flavor with a refreshing clean finish. Unlike conventional sake, funaguchi is un-diluted, cask strength whopping 19% abv, making it an all around flavor you will love

### Cordials and Amaro

- **Disaronno Amaretto** — $14.00
- **Frangelico** — $14.00
- **Five Farms Irish Cream** — $16.00
- **Aperol** — $15.00
- **Campari** — $15.00
- **Yellow Chartreuse** — $18.00
- **Green Chartreuse** — $18.00
- **Amaro Montenegro** — $15.00
- **Amaro Nonino** — $16.00
- **Fernet-Branca** — $15.00
- **Disaronno Amaretto** — $14.00
- **Frangelico** — $14.00
- **Five Farms Irish Cream** — $16.00
- **Aperol** — $15.00
- **Campari** — $15.00
- **Yellow Chartreuse** — $18.00
- **Green Chartreuse** — $18.00
- **Amaro Montenegro** — $15.00
- **Amaro Nonino** — $16.00
- **Fernet-Branca** — $15.00

### Junmai Ginjo

- **Tensei Song of the Sea** — 6oz$19.00 / Bottle$74.00
  Medlies of apple, banana and melon lead the aromas and carry through on the palate. Saltwater taffy salinity notes add a touch of sweetness and minerality with an intense crisp, clean finish

### Daiginjo

- **Higashiyama Konteki Tears of Dawn** — 6oz$21.00 / Bottle$82.00
  Lush notes of tropical banana, anise seed and truffle. These flavors come through the full-bodied palate followed by a velvety and smooth finish

### Junmai Daiginjo

- **Higashiyama Konteki Pearls of Simplicity** — 6oz$23.00 / Bottle$90.00
  Aromas of white flower and asian pear followed by clean flavors of honeydew, lemon and a hint of licorice. Elegant finish with rich minerality and texture

### Maki

- **Shrimp Tempura (Maki)**
  avocado, cucumber, sweet soy

## Wine List

- Prosecco, zonin Prosecco (Glera, Italy) — $14 glass / $54 bottle
- Sparkling Rosé, grattien & meyer Sparkling Rosé (Rosé, fr) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Champagne, moët & chandon Champagne NV (Champagne Blend, Champagne) — $24 glass
- Champagne, veuve clicquot Champagne NV (Champagne Blend, Champagne) — $120 bottle
- Rosé Champagne, billecart-salmon Rosé Champagne NV (Champagne Blend, Champagne) — $130 bottle
- Champagne, gosset grand reserve Champagne NV (Champagne Blend, Champagne) — $180 bottle
- Champagne, dom pérignon Champagne 2015 (Champagne Blend, Champagne) — $260 bottle
- Rosé, ack cotes de provence Rosé (Rosé, fr) — $14 glass / $54 bottle
- Rosé, château miraval Rosé 2025 (Rosé, Provence) — $38 bottle
- Rosé, château d’esclan, whispering angel Rosé 2025 (Rosé, Provence) — $58 bottle
- Rosé, arnot-roberts Rosé 2025 (Rosé, lake county, ca) — $68 bottle
- Rosé, peyrassol reserve des templiers Rosé 2025 (Rosé, Provence) — $72 bottle
- Pinot Grigio, barone fini Pinot Grigio (Pinot Gris, it) — $14 glass / $54 bottle
- Sauvignon Blanc, crowded house Sauvignon Blanc (Sauvignon Blanc, nz) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Sancerre, hubert brochard Sancerre (Sauvignon Blanc, Loire) — $22 glass / $86 bottle
- Sauvignon Blanc, whitehaven Sauvignon Blanc 2024 (Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand) — $38 bottle
- Pinot Grigio, livio felluga Pinot Grigio 2023 (Pinot Gris, Friuli, Italy) — $62 bottle
- Pinot Gris, nantucket vineyard Pinot Gris (Pinot Gris) — $48 bottle
- Sauvignon Blanc, loveblock Sauvignon Blanc 2024 (Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand) — $58 bottle
- Sauvignon Blanc, merry edwards Sauvignon Blanc 2023 (Sauvignon Blanc, Sonoma, California) — $94 bottle
- Sancerre, alphonse mellot la moussiere Sancerre 2024 (Sauvignon Blanc, Loire) — $90 bottle
- Chardonnay, chalk hill Chardonnay (Chardonnay, Sonoma, California) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Chardonnay, domaine des deux roches Chardonnay (Chardonnay, Burgundy) — $18 glass / $70 bottle
- Chablis, la chablisienne le finage Chablis (Chardonnay, Chablis, Burgundy) — $20 glass / $78 bottle
- Côtes-Du-Rhône Blanc, e. guigal Côtes-Du-Rhône Blanc 2024 (Rhône) — $58 bottle
- Chardonnay, au bon climat los alamos Chardonnay 2021 (Chardonnay, California) — $70 bottle
- Chardonnay, rombauer Chardonnay 2024 (Chardonnay, carneros, ca) — $78 bottle
- Chardonnay, olivier leflavie meursault Chardonnay 2022 (Chardonnay, Burgundy) — $150 bottle
- Pinot Noir, la crema Pinot Noir (Pinot Noir, California) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Pinot Noir, pike road Pinot Noir (Pinot Noir, Oregon) — $18 glass / $70 bottle
- Gamay, marcel lapierre raisins gaulois Gamay 2024 (Gamay, Beaujolais, Burgundy) — $58 bottle
- Gamay, lapierre morgon Gamay 2021 (Gamay, Beaujolais, Burgundy) — $120 bottle
- Pinot Noir, ken wright shea vineyard Pinot Noir 2021 (Pinot Noir, Oregon) — $58 bottle
- Pinot Noir, flowers Pinot Noir 2023 (Pinot Noir, Sonoma, California) — $88 bottle
- Pinot Noir, raen royal st robert Pinot Noir 2023 (Pinot Noir, Sonoma, California) — $110 bottle
- Pinot Noir, comte lafon mothélie 1er cru Pinot Noir 2022 (Pinot Noir, Burgundy) — $140 bottle
- Cotes-du-Rhone, chateau de saint cosme Cotes-du-Rhone (Rhône) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Chianti Classico, cultusboni Chianti Classico (Sangiovese, Tuscany, Italy) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Zinfandel, ridge geyserville Zinfandel 2022 (Zinfandel, Sonoma, California) — $88 bottle
- Syrah, melville estate Syrah 2021 (Syrah, California) — $74 bottle
- Brunello di Montalcino, villa poggio salvi Brunello di Montalcino 2019 (Sangiovese, Tuscany, Italy) — $94 bottle
- Barolo, Paolo Scavino Barolo 2021 (Nebbiolo, Piedmont, Italy) — $88 bottle
- Barolo, elio grasso ginestra casa maté Barolo 2020 (Nebbiolo, Piedmont, Italy) — $130 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, juggernaut Cabernet Sauvignon (Cabernet Sauvignon, ca) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, chateau fontanes les traverses Cabernet Sauvignon (Cabernet Sauvignon, fr) — $16 glass / $62 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, caymus Cabernet Sauvignon (Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, California) — $28 glass / $138 bottle
- Super Tuscan, gaja ca’marcanda promiss Super Tuscan 2023 (Tuscany, Italy) — $84 bottle
- Rioja, la rioja alta ardanza reserva Rioja 2019 (Tempranillo, Spain) — $80 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, long meadow ranch Cabernet Sauvignon 2018 (Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, California) — $62 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, orin swift palermo Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 (Cabernet Sauvignon, ca) — $92 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, bv rutherford reserve Cabernet Sauvignon 2021 (Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, California) — $100 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, jordan Cabernet Sauvignon 2021 (Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma, California) — $100 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, silver oak Cabernet Sauvignon 2020 (Cabernet Sauvignon, Sonoma, California) — $140 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, mt brave Cabernet Sauvignon 2019 (Cabernet Sauvignon, mt veeder, ca) — $160 bottle
- Meritage Blend, opus one Meritage Blend 2022 (Napa Valley, California) — $420 bottle
- Cabernet Sauvignon, schrader double diamond Cabernet Sauvignon 2022 (Cabernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley, California) — $250 bottle

## Sources

Menu data verified 2026-07-13.

- Official site: https://www.brotherhoodnantucket.com/
- Wine, Wine by the Glass menu: https://media-cdn.getbento.com/accounts/7f37b5118519f806fcbe4bf92849c0ab/media/sw3zP3VwRDmlYEzG7X6l_no%20marks_BOT%20MENU_8.5x14_Dinner_4.21.26_PRINT.pdf (2026-07-01)

---
Indexed by Nantucket Dining — https://nantucketdining.com/restaurants/brotherhood-of-thieves