Nantucket Island, Massachusetts
Mid-Island Restaurants
24 Mid-Island restaurants with current menus and prices. Where locals eat: sandwich shops, pizza, bakeries and pubs along Sparks Avenue, Orange Street and Old South Road. Every menu is checked weekly; last refreshed September 10, 2026.
Browse by area
Mid-Island Restaurants: all listings
45 Surfside Bakery and Café
$Bakery / Cafe
45 Surfside Rd.
8 Arms Chef Service
Catering / Private Chef
5 Amelia Drive, Nantucket, MA 02554
The Boathouse (Barcos y Tacos)
$$Mexican / American
2 Sanford Rd.
The Fairgrounds
$$27 Fairgrounds Rd.
Fusaro’s
$$$17 Old South Road
Henry, Jr. Sandwich Shop
$Deli / Sandwiches
129 Orange Street
Island Blend
$$$Mediterranean
149 Orange Street
Island Kitchen
$$American (New)
2 Chin’s Way
Kitty Murtaugh's
$$Irish / American
4 West Creek Road
Millies Mid-Island @ Rotary
$$$1 Sparks Avenue
Nantucket Bake Shop
$Bakery
17½ Old South Road
Nantucket Meat & Fish
Butcher / Seafood Market
21 Old South Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554
Pi Pizzeria
$$$11 West Creek Rd.
Pip and Anchor
$$14 Amelia Drive
Roastd @ Stop & Shop
$$Coffee / General Store
31 Sparks Ave
Salvadorena Food & Market
Salvadoran / Latin
63B Old South Road, Nantucket, MA 02554
Sayle's Seafood
$$$Seafood
99 Washington St. Ext.
SeaGrille
$$$$45 Sparks Avenue
Siam @ the Hive
Thai
5 Amelia Drive, Nantucket, MA 02554
Sophie T's Pizza
$$Pizza
7 Dave’s Street
Sushi Sean's 11:11 Market & Bistro
$$$$Japanese / Sushi
130 Pleasant Street
Wicked Island Bakery
$Bakery
7B Bayberry Court
Yezzi’s
$$57 Old South Road
Yummy
$$63 Surfside Road
About the Nantucket restaurant directory
The directory covers the restaurants open on Nantucket this season. For each one we record the menu the restaurant itself publishes, every dish, description and price as printed, along with the wine list where there is one, and check it weekly. Restaurant pages show the full menu, a price ribbon that places the restaurant against the island-wide distribution, and a map pin.
Prices are never estimated. A restaurant that publishes a menu without prices is listed with its dishes but no numbers, and a restaurant with no readable menu is listed with its address, hours and cuisine only. For island-wide comparisons, such as the cheapest lobster roll or the most gluten-free options, the AI guide and the Island Guides draw on the same data.
Frequently asked questions
How many restaurants does the Nantucket directory list?
- 109 restaurants, cafes, bakeries and food trucks on Nantucket Island, 102 of them with a published menu. 62 are downtown and 24 are mid-island; the rest are in 'Sconset, around the airport, and along the beaches.
Where do the menus and prices come from?
- Each restaurant's own published menu. Menus are checked weekly during the season and prices are recorded as printed. This directory was last refreshed on September 10, 2026.
What do the $ price tiers mean?
- Tiers summarize a restaurant's typical menu prices: $ is casual and inexpensive, $$ moderate, $$$ upscale, and $$$$ the island's fine-dining tier. Each restaurant page shows the actual price of every dish and where it sits against the island-wide distribution.
Can I search Nantucket restaurants by dish or vibe?
- Yes. The search box at the top of the directory takes plain English, such as 'oysters and champagne' or 'cheap quick breakfast', and ranks restaurants by their actual menus. For comparisons and prices across the island, ask the AI guide on the home page.
Are Nantucket wine lists included?
- Yes. 3,339 wines with glass and bottle prices are indexed from the restaurants that publish a list, and each restaurant page has a Cellar section.